As a dedicated runner and fitness enthusiast, I’ve spent countless hours testing treadmills to find the perfect fit for my home gym. Recently, I had the opportunity to compare two premium contenders head-to-head: the Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Commercial 2450. Both are celebrated for their advanced features, immersive training platforms, and sleek designs, but they cater to slightly different needs.
Below, I share my personal experience with each treadmill, breaking down their performance, features, and overall value to help you decide which one deserves a spot in your home. This review is tailored for Treadmill Review Guru, where I aim to provide honest, hands-on insights.
See the latest Top-Rated Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Price Today Used by Champion Runners.
First Impressions and Design
Peloton Tread
The Peloton Tread immediately stands out with its minimalist, modern aesthetic. Its black frame with a bold red centerline on the belt screams style, and the 23.8-inch HD touchscreen is a focal point. At 68” L x 33” W x 62” H, it’s compact for a high-end treadmill, but it doesn’t fold, so you’ll need a dedicated space. The treadmill feels sturdy, with a 300-pound weight capacity, though I noticed the screen shakes slightly at higher speeds due to its single-bar attachment. The adjustment knobs for speed and incline on the handles are a game-changer, offering intuitive control during intense runs.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
The NordicTrack 2450, while slightly larger at 77.3” L x 37” W x 63.4” H, also boasts a sleek, contemporary design inspired by the Peloton’s z-shaped frame. Its 22-inch pivoting touchscreen is a standout, allowing for off-treadmill workouts like yoga or strength training. The folding deck with hydraulic lift assist is a huge plus for those with limited space, though lifting the 50-pound deck requires some effort. With a 400-pound weight capacity, it feels incredibly stable, and the screen remains steady even at top speeds. The console has minimal physical buttons, relying heavily on the touchscreen, which can be tricky to navigate mid-run.
Winner: NordicTrack 2450 for its folding capability and pivoting screen, which add versatility for smaller spaces and diverse workouts. However, the Peloton’s compact footprint and stylish design are hard to beat for a dedicated setup.
Running Experience and Performance
Peloton Tread
Running on the Peloton Tread feels like hitting the pavement, thanks to its firm 20” x 59” deck. While this firmness mimics outdoor running, it can be jarring for longer sessions, especially if you have joint sensitivity. The 3.0 HP DC motor powers a max speed of 12.5 mph and a 12.5% incline, but it lacks a decline option. The motor is responsive, though I noticed slight lag when adjusting speed via the touchscreen (the knobs are faster). The Auto-Incline feature syncs with instructor cues, making classes feel seamless, but it’s not as hands-free as NordicTrack’s equivalent. The deck’s red centerline keeps you aligned, but I didn’t find it essential.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
The NordicTrack 2450’s 20” x 60” deck is a revelation, offering the softest cushioning I’ve experienced on a treadmill. It absorbs shock beautifully, leaving my ankles and knees pain-free even after 10-mile runs. The 4.25 CHP motor is a beast, hitting 14 mph and adjusting speed and incline (up to 12%, down to -3%) faster than the Peloton. The AutoAdjust technology in iFIT workouts automatically tweaks speed and incline to match terrain or instructor cues, allowing me to focus entirely on my run. The deck’s size and cushioning make it ideal for runners of all strides, and the decline option adds variety for race training.
Winner: NordicTrack 2450 for its superior cushioning, more powerful motor, and decline feature, which make it more comfortable and versatile for serious runners.
Training Platforms and Content
Peloton Tread
Peloton’s All-Access Membership ($44/month) is the heart of the Tread experience. The live and on-demand classes are unmatched, with charismatic instructors like Robin Arzón and Jess King leading high-energy runs fueled by curated playlists. The leaderboard fosters a competitive vibe, and I loved challenging friends during live sessions. The 23.8-inch touchscreen delivers crisp visuals, though it only tilts, not pivots. Metrics like speed, pace, and heart rate (via my Apple Watch) are clearly displayed, but the lack of third-party app integration (e.g., Netflix) limits entertainment options. The content shines for studio-style classes but lacks outdoor or scenic runs.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
The NordicTrack 2450 pairs with iFIT ($39/month), which offers over 16,000 classes, including studio workouts and immersive outdoor runs filmed worldwide. Instructors like Tommy Rivs bring personality, though they don’t match Peloton’s star power. The Google Maps feature lets you run custom routes, like Central Park, with AutoAdjust mimicking the terrain. The ability to stream Netflix, Spotify, and Amazon Prime Video (with an iFIT subscription) on the 22-inch touchscreen made long runs fly by. The pivoting screen is perfect for following iFIT’s strength or yoga classes off the treadmill. However, the iFIT interface feels less intuitive than Peloton’s.
Winner: Tie. Peloton excels for its engaging live classes and community-driven experience, while NordicTrack’s diverse content, scenic runs, and streaming apps offer more variety. Your preference depends on whether you prioritize studio energy or immersive outdoor workouts.
Additional Features and Usability
Peloton Tread
The Peloton Tread’s knobs for speed and incline adjustments are a highlight, making mid-run tweaks effortless. The front-facing speakers are loud, but I wished for Bluetooth connectivity to play my own music. The storage tray is minimal, barely fitting my phone and a small water bottle. The lack of a fan was noticeable during sweaty sessions. Setup was straightforward, and Peloton’s delivery team handled installation seamlessly. However, the non-folding design and 300-pound weight make it hard to move.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
The NordicTrack 2450 includes a fan, dual cup holders (securely holding my 40 oz HydroJug), and a small phone cubby. The speakers are decent, and Bluetooth connectivity lets you pair headphones. The touchscreen’s responsiveness is solid, but I missed physical quick-adjust buttons for speed and incline, as tapping the screen while running is imprecise. The folding deck and hydraulic assist are practical, though moving the 350-pound treadmill requires planning. Assembly took longer than the Peloton, but NordicTrack’s instructions were clear. The lifetime motor warranty adds peace of mind.
Winner: NordicTrack 2450 for its practical features (fan, cup holders, folding deck) and longer warranty, though Peloton’s knobs are more user-friendly during runs.
Price and Value
Peloton Tread
The Peloton Tread starts at $2,995, with bundles ranging from $3,740 to $3,820 for extras like weights and mats. The $44/month All-Access Membership is required for full functionality, pushing the long-term cost higher. While the build quality and content are premium, the lack of decline, folding capability, and third-party app support makes it feel less versatile for the price.
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Priced around $2,999, the NordicTrack 2450 is comparable upfront but offers more features, including a folding deck, decline, and streaming apps. The iFIT subscription ($39/month) is slightly cheaper, and the lifetime motor warranty enhances value. The 2450’s durability and versatility make it a better long-term investment for runners seeking a comprehensive training experience.
Winner: NordicTrack 2450 for its feature-rich design and lower subscription cost, offering better value for serious runners and multi-user households.
See the latest Top-Rated Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Price Today Used by Champion Runners.
Pros and Cons
Peloton Tread
Pros:
- Sleek, compact design
- Intuitive speed and incline knobs
- Engaging live classes with leaderboard
- Crisp 23.8-inch HD touchscreen
- Seamless heart rate monitor integration
Cons:
- Firm deck may cause discomfort
- No decline or folding capability
- Limited entertainment options
- Screen shakes at high speeds
- Higher subscription cost ($44/month)
NordicTrack Commercial 2450
Pros:
- Soft, joint-friendly cushioning
- Powerful 4.25 CHP motor with 14 mph max speed
- Folding deck with hydraulic assist
- Pivoting 22-inch touchscreen with streaming apps
- Decline feature and lifetime motor warranty
Cons:
- Larger footprint when unfolded
- Touchscreen navigation can be tricky mid-run
- iFIT interface less polished than Peloton
- Deck is heavy to fold
- Assembly takes longer
Customer Reviews:
Just bought the NordicTrack T5, and it’s easily the best treadmill I’ve owned. The frame is solid, the belt runs smooth, and the cushioning makes a big difference on my knees. The touchscreen is sharp and responsive, and syncing it with iFit adds real value. No more boring runs.
The built-in workouts are legit, and the incline adjustments are fast and quiet. Setup was straightforward. It runs quiet, which matters in my house. I use it daily, and it’s been consistent. No lags, no shaking, no nonsense. If you want a serious treadmill without dropping $3,000, this one delivers. Buy it if you’re done wasting time on cheap machines. – Ally Rounsville
You need 2 people to assemble this one. That screw on the right side gave me a HARD TIME!! I needed up rubbing olive oil on the back of the screw and hammering it to loosen it up. Once the first RIDICULOUS part is completed and the right panel screw is removed, a third-grader could assemble it hassle free. It works great; doesn’t threaten to fall to pieces when running or walking and the belt is smooth and almost soft enough to go barefoot on it. It’s not noisy, but not whisper quiet either. If you’re over 300 pounds this might not be for you. – Deebo
The treadmill is very sturdy and works great! Installation was pretty simple and easy directions to follow. Our only complaint is that in looking at the images before buying, it shows that the treadmill can fold up, which is one of the reasons we bought this model. Upon receiving it and putting it together, we realized that this model does not fold up like one of the pictures show. We were pretty disappointed by the false advertising, as the folding feature was one of the main reasons we chose this model. – Paula Pisney
Final Verdict
After running dozens of miles on both treadmills, the NordicTrack Commercial 2450 is my top pick for most home gym users. Its soft cushioning, powerful motor, decline option, and folding deck make it more comfortable and versatile, especially for runners training for races or those with joint concerns. The pivoting touchscreen and streaming apps add entertainment value, and the lower subscription cost seals the deal. However, the Peloton Tread is a fantastic choice if you thrive on live, studio-style classes and prefer a compact, stylish design. Its community-driven platform and intuitive knobs are perfect for those who prioritize motivation and competition.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your priorities. If you want a treadmill that feels like an outdoor run with endless content variety, go with the NordicTrack 2450. If you’re hooked on Peloton’s instructors and leaderboard, the Tread won’t disappoint. Both are exceptional, but the NordicTrack 2450’s versatility makes it the champion for my home gym.
For more treadmill comparisons and reviews, visit Treadmill Review Guru.
See the latest Top-Rated Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Price Today Used by Champion Runners.
FAQs
Is the Peloton treadmill the best?
The Peloton Treadmill is highly regarded for its immersive, instructor-led classes and sleek design, especially if you prioritize interactive studio workouts. However, “best” is subjective and depends on individual preferences like budget, features, and workout style.
Which treadmill is closest to Peloton?
Many experts consider NordicTrack Commercial Series treadmills, particularly the NordicTrack Commercial 1750, to be the closest to Peloton. Both brands offer immersive, interactive training platforms (iFIT for NordicTrack, Peloton App for Peloton) and high-quality machines.
Why did Peloton stop selling Tread?
Peloton issued a voluntary recall of its Tread and Tread+ models in May 2021 due to safety concerns, including incidents of injuries and a child’s death. While they later reintroduced a revised Tread, they initially paused sales and offered refunds due to these safety issues and related controversies regarding “Just Run” feature access.
What is the highest quality treadmill?
Many sources frequently cite high-end models from brands like Woodway, NordicTrack (e.g., Commercial 1750, X32i), Sole (e.g., F85), and sometimes Peloton Tread+ as among the highest quality. These typically feature robust motors, superior cushioning, and advanced technology.
Which is better, NordicTrack or Peloton?
Neither is definitively “better”; it depends on your priority. Peloton excels in live, studio-style classes and community. NordicTrack, powered by iFIT, offers more diverse content, including immersive outdoor simulations with auto-adjusting terrain, and often has a wider range of treadmill models with varying features and price points, including folding options.
Is the NordicTrack 2450 a good treadmill?
Yes, the NordicTrack Commercial 2450 is generally considered a very good treadmill. It features a powerful motor, a large touchscreen with iFIT integration, incline and decline capabilities, and a comfortable cushioned deck, making it suitable for serious runners and diverse workouts.
Can you use NordicTrack 2450 without iFIT?
Yes, you can use the NordicTrack 2450 in manual mode without an active iFIT subscription. However, many of the advanced features, such as automatic trainer control, the full workout library, and integrated streaming apps like Netflix, require a paid iFIT membership.
Can I watch Netflix on my NordicTrack 2450?
Yes, you can typically watch Netflix and other streaming apps on your NordicTrack 2450’s screen, but this usually requires an active iFIT Pro Membership. Without the paid membership, access to third-party streaming apps is generally not available directly through the console.
What is the difference between Peloton Tread and iFIT?
Peloton Tread provides access to Peloton’s ecosystem of live and on-demand studio classes, focusing on high-energy, instructor-led workouts with a strong community feel. iFIT, used by NordicTrack, offers a broader range of content, including global scenic workouts with automatic incline/decline adjustments to match the terrain, as well as studio classes and other wellness content.
What is the difference between the Peloton treadmill and the NordicTrack 2450 treadmill?
Key differences include:
- Subscription Focus: Peloton is heavily integrated with its class-based ecosystem; NordicTrack 2450 uses iFIT for diverse workouts.
- Features: The NordicTrack 2450 typically offers decline (Peloton Tread does not), a more powerful motor, and a folding design (Peloton Tread is non-folding).
- Deck: Peloton Tread has a firm running deck, while NordicTrack 2450 often has more cushioning.
- Screen Movement: NordicTrack 2450’s screen usually pivots, unlike Peloton Tread’s.
See the latest Top-Rated Peloton Tread vs NordicTrack Price Today Used by Champion Runners.
Founder, Owner, and CEO of TaekwondoKing.
He is one of the top 100 martial artists in the World and among the top 20 referees in Bangladesh.
Ehatasamul Alom is an esteemed Kukkiwon Certified Taekwondo 3rd Dan Black Belt with over 15 years of experience in this dynamic martial art. Born in Rajshahi, Bangladesh, Ehatasamul’s journey with Taekwondo began at the tender age of seven. His passion led him to compete at national and international levels, where he has bagged numerous awards and honors. He is also a member of the Taekwondo National Referee Panel.
With a Bachelor’s degree in Sports Science from the prestigious Rajshahi University, Ehatasamul has a deep understanding of the technical and scientific aspects of martial arts and some other martial arts.
In 2022, Ehatasamul created the “TaekwondoKing.com” blog to share his knowledge and Real experiences. His articles focus on Taekwondo training techniques, competition strategies, and the art’s rich history and philosophy. He also writes about the importance of mental fortitude and discipline, key aspects of his teaching philosophy. His goal is to inspire both beginners and seasoned practitioners worldwide through insightful and engaging content.
If you need any help, contact Ehatasamul Alom at any time.
